All questions › Choosing & Vetting an MSP
Choosing & Vetting an MSP
How to pick a provider you can trust: the vetting questions, the red flags, and what good answers sound like. 12 questions, answered in plain English.
- What does a managed IT provider (MSP) actually do?An MSP is your outsourced IT department: it monitors and maintains your systems 24/7, secures them, backs them up, and gives your team a help desk to call, all for a flat monthly fee.
- What questions should I ask before hiring an MSP?Ask who owns your passwords and licenses (must be you), where the techs are located, what's excluded from the monthly fee, how fast they respond, and how they'll hand everything back if you leave.
- How do I switch IT providers without downtime?A proper MSP transition runs the new provider's tools in parallel with the old ones before cutover, so there's never a coverage gap. Expect discovery, credential transfer, parallel onboarding, then a coordinated switch date.
- We have an internal IT person. Can an MSP work alongside them?Yes: it's called co-managed IT. The MSP supplies the 24/7 monitoring, security stack, and overflow help desk; your internal person keeps the strategic and hands-on work they're best at.
- Our internal IT person is leaving (or being let go). How do we move to an external provider safely?This transition is very manageable, but the security steps matter: document and transfer every credential BEFORE the departure, rotate passwords and disable access on exit day, and bring the MSP in early enough to map the environment while knowledge is still in the building.
- Is there one company that can handle computer security, the network, and even security cameras, without juggling multiple vendors?Yes, that consolidation is one of the main reasons businesses hire an MSP: computers, cybersecurity, networking, and cameras managed by one team under one agreement, with one number to call and no vendors pointing fingers at each other.
- Is it really better for most companies to have both an MSP and an internal IT person?Not for most: below roughly 40 to 50 employees, a good MSP alone usually covers everything for far less than a salary. The both-together model (co-managed IT) earns its keep in larger or more complex businesses where an internal person adds daily on-the-ground value.
- I had an MSP before and they never answered my calls, overcharged me, and never listened. Why would it be different this time?You were not wrong to leave; those are provider failures, not proof the model fails. The fix is vetting differently this time: response commitments in writing, itemized billing, local accountability, and references you actually call. A good MSP is happy to be held to all four.
- If I sign with an MSP and later want to switch to a different one, will I have to start all over? Will they hold my passwords hostage?With a professional provider, no: transitions are a routine, cooperative handoff, and your credentials and documentation belong to you the whole time. The hostage scenario comes from unprofessional providers, which is why exit terms are something to verify before you sign, not when you leave.
- Are your employees background-checked? Is your company insured?Both questions belong in every MSP interview. Technicians will hold administrator access to everything your business runs on, so background checks should be standard, and a professional provider carries liability, errors and omissions, and cyber insurance, and can show you proof the same day you ask.
- How long has your IT company been in business, and does it matter?It matters more than people think. An MSP that has operated for years has survived economic cycles, kept clients happy enough to stay, and built processes that outlast any one employee. History is a reasonable predictor of whether they will still be here in five years, and that matters because switching providers is work.
- Should we ask an MSP if they have experience in our line of business?Yes, and ask it directly: how many clients do you have in our industry, and which of our systems do you already support? Industry experience lives in the software, compliance rules, and workflow rhythms a provider already knows, and it shortens every support call you will ever make.
Want a straight answer about your setup?
Asheville Computer Company is a local managed IT provider based in Arden, minutes from most of Asheville.
Call (828) 290-9092 or visit ashevillecomputercompany.com for a free, no-pressure consultation.